Your first employee is a legal and tax change, not just a staffing one. Before the first paycheck you need to confirm you actually need an employee, register for the right employer accounts, collect two federal forms (Form W-4 and Form I-9), and have a payroll process that works every pay period. This checklist walks through the order.
It covers the federal basics and points to where state rules take over. Rules differ by state and by situation, so treat it as a planning guide and confirm details with your CPA or an employment attorney.
Key takeaways
- Define the work first: a clear role description prevents most bad first hires.
- Get an Employer Identification Number (EIN) and set up state employer accounts before the start date.
- Collect a signed Form W-4 and complete Form I-9 for every new employee, citizen or not.
- Decide how payroll will run, who reviews it, and where records are kept.
- Contractor or employee is decided by the facts of the relationship, not by the label you choose.
Do you actually need an employee?
Hiring adds a fixed monthly cost, plus employer taxes and administration. Before you post a job, write down what the work is, how many hours a week it takes, and what you would stop doing yourself. If the work is occasional or project-based, a contractor, part-time help or better workflows may fit better. Our guides to identifying workflow bottlenecks and the priority matrix can help you see whether the real problem is capacity or a process that wastes time.
Can you afford the hire?
Do not budget only for wages. Add employer payroll taxes, any workers' compensation insurance your state requires, equipment, software, training time, and the weeks it takes a new person to become productive. A hypothetical example: if you plan a part-time role, build a simple monthly cost line with every item above, then test it against your 13-week cash flow forecast. Your CPA can give the exact tax rates that apply to you.
Is this person an employee or a contractor?
Calling someone a contractor does not make them one. The classification depends on the actual working relationship, such as how much control you have over how and when the work is done. Misclassification can lead to back taxes and penalties, so if you are unsure, ask your CPA or an employment attorney before the person starts.
What should you set up before the first day?
- Employer Identification Number (EIN). The IRS lists applying for an EIN as an early step when hiring employees.
- State and local registrations. States typically have their own employer withholding, unemployment insurance and new-hire reporting requirements. Check your state agencies' sites, because the deadlines and forms vary.
- Workers' compensation. Requirements differ by state. Ask your state workers' compensation agency or your insurance agent what applies to you.
- Payroll process. Decide whether you will use a payroll provider or run payroll yourself, who approves each run, and how often you pay.
- Recordkeeping. Choose one secure place for each employee's forms and keep it separate from the general business files.
- Written role and expectations. A one-page description of duties, pay, schedule and who the person reports to.
Which forms does a new employee complete?
Form W-4, Employee's Withholding Certificate. The IRS says to ask all new employees for a signed Form W-4 when they start work and to make it effective with the first wage payment. If a new employee does not give you one, withhold tax as if the employee is single. A W-4 stays in effect until the employee gives you a new one.
Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification. The IRS states that all U.S. employers must complete Form I-9 for every individual they hire, citizens and noncitizens alike. Both the employee and the employer complete parts of it. USCIS says not to file it with USCIS or ICE, and to keep it for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later, available for inspection by authorized government officials. Use the USCIS Form I-9 page for the current form and instructions, including the deadlines for each section.
Name and Social Security number. The IRS says you are required to get each employee's name and SSN and enter them on Form W-2, so make sure the name matches the Social Security card.
State forms. Many states have their own withholding certificate and a requirement to report new hires to a state directory. Look up your state's deadline now rather than after the start date.
What should the first weeks look like?
New hires often struggle because expectations are unclear, not because they lack skill. Write down the three or four tasks the person will do first, who they ask when stuck, and how you will check in. If a task is repeatable, document it as a standard operating procedure instead of explaining it verbally each time. Our guide to a repeatable client onboarding process applies the same idea to customers, and the approach carries over to employees.
First-hire checklist
- Role, hours and budget are written down.
- The employee-versus-contractor question was checked with a professional if unclear.
- EIN is in place.
- State employer registrations and workers' compensation requirements were checked.
- Your state's new-hire reporting deadline is on the calendar.
- Signed Form W-4 collected and effective with the first wage payment.
- Form I-9 completed by the deadlines in the USCIS instructions and stored (not filed with USCIS).
- Payroll process, approver and pay schedule decided.
- First-week plan and a check-in schedule written.
What mistakes do first-time employers make?
- Starting work before the paperwork. Collect forms before or on the first day, not weeks later.
- Treating a worker as a contractor by default. The label does not decide the classification.
- Forgetting state requirements. Federal steps are only part of the list.
- Mixing HR files with the general folder. Employee documents hold sensitive data and need limited access.
- No plan for the first month. Without one, the hire lands on your desk instead of taking work off it.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an EIN before I hire someone?
The IRS lists getting an Employer Identification Number (EIN) among the first steps when you hire employees. Check the IRS hiring page and your payroll provider for how it applies to your business type.
Can I just pay someone as a contractor to avoid payroll?
Not automatically. Whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor depends on the facts of the working relationship, not on what you call it. Ask your CPA or an employment attorney before you decide.
What happens if a new employee does not give me a Form W-4?
The IRS says to withhold tax as if the employee is single. It is better to collect a signed W-4 when they start, and to make it effective with the first wage payment.
Do I send the Form I-9 to the government?
No. USCIS says not to file Form I-9 with USCIS or ICE. You keep it and retain it for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later.
Should I use a payroll provider?
Many small employers do, because it handles withholding calculations and filings. It does not remove your responsibility, so you still need to review what it files on your behalf.
Where to start
Start with the role description and the monthly cost line, then work down the setup list in order. If you are not sure a hire is the right fix, look at where time is being lost first: the Workflow Clarity Assessment is one advisory option, and Find your starting point can help you choose a next step.